Well, I came back without a guitar. I got to stop and both shops and play a bunch of guitars. The Kilpatrick was alright but something just didn't sound right to me and the finish on the back and sides really bothered me. Not sure if it was intentional but it looked like he just didn't do a great job of filling the wood. Just kind of looked amateurish. And for that kind of price, I'm sorry, but I expected better.
I stopped in at Madison Music after and played a used Huss and Dalton OOO that was much better.
They also had a really nice OO-SP (black acacia), gorgeous and it sounded like a little cannon.