Topic: TV Show Draft Tournament - Semifinals

[charlie]

Ok, quarterfinals are over. There was no tie so no thumb war this time. We're down to four...

Playoff Seeds (Draft Order in Parentheses)

• ober (9)
• PJYelton (3)
• axon (2)
• kermi3 (7)
• Perspective (1)
• micah (8)
• charlie (4)
• KnuckleBuckett (5)
• Phil (6)

Vote for your favorite collection of TV Shows using any rationale you'd like. You can vote for yourself.

This poll expires in 4 days. Then we'll have the finals.

(individual lists below...)

[charlie]

ober

• Lost
• Entourage
• Dirty Jobs
• Modern Marvels
• Animaniacs
• Gilligan's Island
• Law & Order: Criminal Intent
• That '70s Show
• 20/20
• The Dukes of Hazzard
• Reno 911!
• Premium Blend

vs.


Perspective

• The Wire
• The Simpsons
• The Office
• The King of Queens
• The X Files
• Hockey Night in Canada
• Curb Your Enthusiasm
• The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air
• Generation Kill
• Everybody Loves Raymond
• Pinky and the Brain
• Win Ben Stein's Money

[charlie]

PJYelton

• House
• Top Chef
• Battlestar Galactica
• 30 Rock
• NFL Monday Night Football
• Monty Python's Flying Circus
• SportsCenter
• I Love Lucy
• Jeopardy!
• Mystery Science Theater 3000
• Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
• The Sopranos

vs.


micah

• Star Trek: The Next Generation
• MacGyver
• Arrested Development
• The A-Team
• DuckTales
• Nova
• Mr. Bean
• The Big Bang Theory
• The Muppet Show
• CHiPs
• Good Eats
• When We Left Earth: The NASA Missions

[ober]

Me and then PJ.  PJ basically won because of his first 2 picks.

[Jake]

ober all the way.

[charlie]

I wonder if my avatar is a subliminal message to vote for the obes. If it is, he deserves it by virtue of his guessing ability.

I picked PJ over micah because despite the fact that The A-Team, CHiPs and MacGyver were all cool picks, I don't know if I really want a full three cheesy 80s shows on my island.

Also, the Sopranos was a steal in the last round.

[micah]

oh come.... I need more votes!!!!!!

[kermi3]

haha!

[PJYelton]

wow, close races!

[ober]

WTF?

[PJYelton]

Hey, who forgot to vote for the top bracket?

[charlie]

Oops.. break one tie, make another.

[charlie]

Ok, well this one actually did end in a tie. I dunno who voted for only one matchup but that person could have been the decider. :shakesfist:

So should we have them pick their top 3 shows or should we have them each make one more selection?

[micah]

i say make them pick what they think are their top 3 shows each.  then we do a run-off vote based soley on those choices.

[charlie]

Ok, good enough for me.

ober, Perspective, please PM me your top 3 shows that you'd like to include in the runoff. You can pick them based on any criteria you'd like, although trying to win the voting isn't a bad strategy.