I'm simmed through the 2011 season, where I did everything in that picture above, because I rock the house. I also won my divisional series MVP.
Charlie had some injury issues in '11, going out for 7 weeks total for a sprained knee and wrist stress fracture. You dominate in AA (6-0, 2.62 73/33 K/BB) and then get called up to majors where you sit on the bench. It's weird. You're a middle reliever in the bigs, you went 5-0 (3 of which were starts, I guess) with a 4.58 ERA and 31K/12BB
ober's been traded to Chicago, where he's a DH/utility infielder. Batting .267 with 14HR 56RBI and 32SB. Not bad at all
Fitlike is doing basically the same as ever. If he could hit the damn ball, he'd have 100 homers, but as his eyes are as bad as his political philosophy, so he's batting .176 as a replacement LF. He's a butcher in the field though, with 9 errors in 29 games.
Canuck had a pretty bad season in Toronto in limited action. He really needs to get traded somewhere where he can get more than 100 AB a year. He did get a WS ring this year though
Also the Tigers have taken the last 3 AL Cy Youngs between Verlander and Bonderman
edit: 4 now, 2 apiece